Report: The Paris Agreement and the Imposition of Questionable Targets on Local Governments

Assertion of Canadian Municipal Autonomy in Climate Policy and Acknowledgment of National Net-Zero Status

The Paris Agreement and the Imposition of Questionable Targets on Local Governments

---

Executive Summary

The Paris Agreement, adopted in 2015, has imposed significant obligations on Canada, including legally binding targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. However, these targets have raised concerns, particularly regarding their scientific grounding and practical implications for local governments. This report outlines the rationale for considering Canada's withdrawal from the Paris Agreement, advocating for a balanced, scientifically informed approach to climate policy that better reflects Canada's unique context.

---

1. The Paris Agreement: An Overview

The Paris Agreement, under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), commits countries to limiting global temperature increases to below 2 degrees Celsius, primarily through the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. Countries submit Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) outlining their specific targets and strategies. While the Agreement is lauded for its ambitious goals, it imposes a one-size-fits-all model that may not be suitable for Canada, a country with unique geographic, economic, and social characteristics.

---

2. The Case for a Balanced Approach to Climate Policy

While the Paris Agreement focuses heavily on CO₂ reduction, it is crucial to recognize that CO₂ constitutes only about 0.04% (400 parts per million) of the Earth's atmosphere, with human activities contributing just 3-4% of this concentration. This context has led many scientists to advocate for a more balanced and scientifically grounded climate policy.

The Clintel Climate Intelligence Group’s Climate Declaration, signed by nearly 2,000 scientists since August 2023—including Patrick Moore, co-founder of Greenpeace—emphasizes that climate science should be less political and that climate policies should be based on solid scientific evidence. The declaration highlights several key points:

• Natural Climate Variability: The geological record shows that Earth's climate has varied significantly over time, with natural factors playing a substantial role in global temperature changes.

• Slower Warming than Predicted: Current climate models often exaggerate the effects of greenhouse gases, with warming occurring at a slower rate than predicted by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).

• CO₂’s Role in Agriculture: CO₂ is essential for plant life, contributing to agricultural productivity and food security.

• Natural Disasters: There is no statistical evidence linking global warming to an increase in the frequency or intensity of natural disasters.

• Adaptation Strategies: The declaration advocates for climate policies that prioritize adaptation strategies using proven, affordable technologies.

This balanced approach calls for a re-evaluation of policies that may prioritize CO₂ reduction at the expense of other critical factors, such as economic stability, energy security, and the well-being of local communities.

---

3. Impacts on Local Governments

Local governments across Canada bear the brunt of implementing the Paris Agreement's mandates. However, these mandates often impose significant financial and operational burdens that may not align with local conditions. Specific challenges include:

• Economic Disruption: Transitioning away from fossil fuels can lead to job losses and economic instability, particularly in regions dependent on resource-based industries.

• Energy Security Risks: Stricter emissions targets may compromise energy security, especially in remote and rural areas that rely on traditional energy sources.

• Reduced Autonomy: Local governments may find their ability to address local priorities constrained by international obligations that do not consider Canada's unique needs.

---

4. The Canadian Context

Canada's unique circumstances necessitate a climate policy that reflects its distinct geographic, demographic, and economic realities:

• Vast Geographic Size and Low Population Density: Canada is the second-largest country in the world, with approximately 90% of its landmass uninhabited. Despite this, Canada contributes only 1.5% of global CO₂ emissions, while its extensive forests and natural landscapes serve as significant carbon sinks.

• Population and Emissions: With a population of just over 39 million (about 0.5% of the global population), Canada's per capita emissions are relatively low, particularly when considering the country’s natural carbon sequestration capabilities.

• Fossil Fuels in Daily Life: Fossil fuels are essential for daily life in Canada, powering transportation, heating homes, generating electricity, and supporting industrial activities. Given the country’s cold climate, dispersed population, and vast distances, fossil fuels remain critical for economic stability and energy security.

• Emergency Preparedness: In emergencies, fossil fuel generators provide essential backup power, highlighting the need for a reliable and flexible energy system.

In light of these factors, it is crucial that Canadian climate policy prioritizes the protection of economic stability, mobility rights, food security, and energy security over rigid CO₂ reduction targets.

---

5. Recommendations for Withdrawal and Alternative Approaches

Given the challenges and concerns outlined above, the following steps are recommended:

1. Evaluate the Impact: Conduct a thorough assessment of the economic, social, and environmental impacts of continued participation in the Paris Agreement on local governments and communities across Canada.

2. Advocate for Withdrawal: Based on this assessment, advocate for Canada's withdrawal from the Paris Agreement, emphasizing the need for policies tailored to Canada's specific conditions and priorities.

3. Promote a Balanced Climate Policy: Develop a national framework that incorporates the principles of the Clintel Climate Intelligence Group’s Climate Declaration, ensuring that climate policies are scientifically grounded and locally appropriate.

4. Enhance Natural Carbon Sequestration: Focus on enhancing and protecting Canada’s natural carbon sinks, such as forests, wetlands, and agricultural lands, as part of a more holistic approach to environmental stewardship.

5. Prioritize Energy Security: Ensure that post-Paris climate policies prioritize energy security, especially for rural and remote communities, to maintain economic stability and safeguard essential services.

---

Conclusion

The Paris Agreement, while well-intentioned, imposes targets that do not fully account for Canada's unique circumstances and needs. By withdrawing from the Agreement and adopting a more balanced and scientifically informed approach to climate policy, Canada can continue to lead in environmental stewardship while protecting the economic and social well-being of its citizens. This approach will allow Canada to address environmental challenges in a way that aligns with its distinct context, ensuring a sustainable and prosperous future for all Canadians.

---

References

• Clintel Climate Intelligence Group. (2023). The Climate Declaration. Retrieved from Clintel.org

• Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). (2021). Sixth Assessment Report. Retrieved from IPCC.ch

• Moore, P. (2023). Remarks on the Role of CO₂ in Climate and Agriculture. Greenpeace Co-founder’s Public Statements.

• Natural Resources Canada. (2022). Canada's Forests and Carbon Sinks. Retrieved from NRCan.gc.ca

• Statistics Canada. (2023). Canadian Population Statistics. Retrieved from StatCan.gc.ca

• United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). (2015). The Paris Agreement. Retrieved from UNFCCC.int

• Government of Canada. (2022). National Inventory Report 1990-2020: Greenhouse Gas Sources and Sinks in Canada. Retrieved from Canada.ca

---

Contact Information:

Maggie Hope Braun
Civic Advocate, KICLEI Canada
info@kiclei.ca

---

Resolution: Assertion of Canadian Municipal Autonomy in Climate Policy and Acknowledgment of National Net-Zero Status

Resolution Assertion Of Canadian Municipal Autonomy In Climate Policy And Acknowledgment Of National Net Zero Status

42.7KB ∙ PDF file

Download

Download

---

Title: Resolution Affirming Municipal Autonomy in Climate Policy and Proclaiming Canada’s Contribution to Net-Zero Carbon Emissions

Date: [Insert Date]

Submitted By: [Insert Name of Municipality]

WHEREAS the Paris Agreement, adopted in 2015 under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), imposes legally binding targets on signatory countries, including Canada, to limit global temperature increases and reduce greenhouse gas emissions; and

WHEREAS the responsibility for meeting these targets has significant implications for local governments, often requiring them to implement measures that may not fully align with their unique economic conditions, energy needs, and social priorities; and

WHEREAS Canada’s vast forests, wetlands, and other natural landscapes serve as significant carbon sinks, effectively balancing the country’s carbon emissions and contributing to a global net-zero carbon status; and

WHEREAS Canada, despite being the second-largest country in the world by land area, contributes only approximately 1.5% of global CO₂ emissions, while its population represents just 0.5% of the global population; and

WHEREAS the Canadian Constitution grants municipalities the authority to manage local affairs, including energy use and environmental stewardship, in ways that best serve their communities; and

WHEREAS local governments are on the front lines of implementing federal and international climate mandates, often without sufficient input or flexibility to tailor these policies to local realities; and

WHEREAS it is essential for municipalities to retain autonomy in developing and implementing climate policies that reflect their specific circumstances and contribute to the overall well-being of their residents;

THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that [Insert Name of Municipality] affirms its autonomy in climate policy and declares that while it recognizes the importance of global efforts to address climate change, it asserts that the responsibility for meeting the targets set by the Paris Agreement rests with the federal government; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that [Insert Name of Municipality] proclaims that Canada, through its vast natural carbon sequestration capabilities and relatively low emissions, is effectively contributing to a global net-zero carbon status, and that this achievement should be recognized and communicated by the federal government in international forums; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that [Insert Name of Municipality] calls upon the federal government to:

1. Acknowledge the significant role of Canada’s natural carbon sinks in achieving a net-zero carbon status.

2. Reassess the distribution of responsibilities and burdens imposed by the Paris Agreement to ensure that local governments are not disproportionately affected and have the flexibility to pursue climate policies that align with local conditions.

3. Engage in meaningful consultation with municipalities when developing and implementing climate policies, ensuring that local voices are heard and respected.

4. Promote a balanced approach to climate policy that includes both mitigation and adaptation strategies, leveraging proven, affordable technologies.

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that [Insert Name of Municipality] will continue to implement and support environmental initiatives that align with its local priorities, contribute to the well-being of its residents, and reflect a balanced approach to environmental stewardship.

---

Adopted by: [Insert Name of Municipality]
Date of Adoption: [Insert Date]
Signed by: [Insert Names and Titles of Municipal Officials]