Thorold's Historic Decision: First Canadian Municipality to Exit the PCP Program
Introduction
On June18, 2024, in a groundbreaking move, the City of Thorold Council has become the first Canadian municipality to withdraw from the Partners for Climate Protection (PCP) program, initiated by the International Council for Local Environmental Initiatives (ICLEI) under the auspices of the United Nations and the Federation of Canadian Municipalities (FCM). This breaking news follows an extensive process of information gathering and passionate delegations from concerned citizens. The meeting, which was well attended with a full council chamber in support of opting out, highlighted the complexities of local climate policies and the challenges of balancing global frameworks with local needs. A well-written article in Thorold Today titled "Partnership Dissolved: Thorold Pulls Out of Climate Program" provides a detailed account of the proceedings and the factors influencing the decision.
Delegations: Voices of the Community
The council meeting featured passionate delegations from residents who supported the staff’s recommendation to withdraw from the PCP program.
Ron Devereaux expressed skepticism about the scientific foundations of the PCP program and broader UN climate initiatives. He argued that natural processes, such as solar variations, play a more significant role in climate change than human activities.
Angela Braun, a former councillor for Thorold, emphasized the importance of local control and proposed forming a local environmental stewardship committee tailored to Thorold's specific needs. She highlighted the disconnect between top-down initiatives and local realities.
Mina Antes raised concerns about the potential privacy infringements and financial burdens imposed by the PCP program. She stressed the importance of local decision-making and the risks associated with handing over detailed data to international organizations.
Maggie Braun provided a detailed critique of the PCP program, highlighting its extensive data collection requirements and potential ethical concerns. She questioned the real-world benefits of the program compared to its costs and advocated for local environmental programs.
Belligerent Questioning from Councillor O'Hare
Councillor O'Hares line of questioning during the meeting was notably belligerent. He aggressively questioned the qualifications and credibility of the delegations, particularly focusing on Maggie Brun’s background and the sources she cited. His confrontational approach included attempts to undermine the legitimacy of the critiques presented, rather than engaging constructively with the concerns raised.
Support from Other Councillors
Despite the heated moments, the majority of councillors expressed support for the staff recommendation.
Councillor DeRose highlighted the importance of focusing on municipal needs and avoiding unnecessary expenditures on a program that might not benefit the community.
Councillor Handley: Emphasized his long-term commitment to environmental stewardship and criticized the lack of direct answers from PCP representatives.
Councillor D'Angela: Supported staff's recommendation and stressed the need to focus on core municipal services and work with regional partners.
Councillor Longo: Highlighted the importance of addressing climate change while working collaboratively with regional efforts.
Councillor Sentence, emphasized his trust in the staff's judgment and their ability to find more suitable solutions in collaboration with the region.
Councillor Dekker, emphasizes the importance of focusing on local needs and the practicality of addressing environmental issues within the city's budget constraints.
Mayor Terry Ugulini emphasizes collaboration with regional partners and local municipalities through the CAO’s working group to ensure the city meets its environmental responsibilities effectively.
Conclusion
In the end, the motion to withdraw from the PCP program passed with a 7-1 vote. The council's decision is a step towards restoring local autonomy and a tailored approach to environmental stewardship. By prioritizing local needs and practical solutions, Thorold aims to address environmentalism in a way that aligns with the community’s values and resources. The council's deliberations underscored the complexities of climate policy implementation and the importance of informed, community-driven decision-making.
Join the KICLEI Movement! 🌍
Unlock the potential of localism and environmental stewardship with KICLEI. Explore our mission, get involved, and stay updated through our various platforms:
Join the KICLEI Network
KICLEI Mission: Join Us
Action Plan
KICLEI Action Plan: Share the Mission
Social Media & Video Platforms
YouTube: KICLEI Canada
Rumble: KICLEI Canada
BitChute: KICLEI Channel
X (Twitter): @kiclei_canada
TikTok: Maggie Dingman
Facebook: Gather 2030
Newsletter & Updates
KICLEI | Gather 2030 | Substack: Subscribe Now
Gather 2030 | Substack: Stay Informed
KICLEI Merch
KICLEI Store: Shop Now
Contribute
Donate to KICLEI: Support Our Mission
Contact Us
For more information, collaboration, or to join our cause, reach out to us at
Email: info@kiclei.ca | gather2030@gmail.com
Great work, Maggie.
It's good to have this precedent. Loved the comment, “parroting the (United Nations) company line," and your mention of 'data harvesting on behalf of private industry.' There's so much to build on here :-)
Good news!